Global Aircraft Forum Help -  Privacy Policy -  Interactive Content Guidelines -  Legal Notices
Global Aircraft Welcome, Guest!   [Log In]  |   [Sign Up]  |   [Return Home]  

GAC Forum

RSS Feed Message Directories
Create New Topic
   RSS Feed Military Chat
   RSS Feed Subject - F/A-22A vs Su-47  [Topic ID# 127]Messages 11 - 19 of 19  

Teknetinium
Subject: F/A-22A vs Su-47
Post ID# 977
Message Number 11
Date Posted: 04 December 2005, 4:37:48 PM

Hi m8ys, I would say that Su-47 vs F-22 is only about the best pilot, And don tell me that F-22 has the stelth, If F-22 wants to fire in BVR, he nedds to switch his Rader on That is giving out his position, wlile the Su-47 dont use his radar becouse he knows that he cant see him, and only using HeatScan, whitch makes it to a cat,dog fight and the best pilot wins whit some luck whit him.

PS: Teknetinium Su-33 pilot in, Lock-On FC.




commodore_vic
Subject: F/A-22A vs Su-47
Post ID# 979
Message Number 12
Date Posted: 07 December 2005, 3:10:39 PM

no way could the su27 beat the f22 because lockheed martin f22 raptor was built as an AIR SUPERIORITY FIGHTER and the USAF ha the best planes in the world because the usaf built the fastest plane (the X43 which goes at mach 9.93 i might add!) and it would be no surprise to anyone that the F15 has not only successfully shot a satellite out of orbit and the F15 has NEVER been shot down in combat! so the f22 is the superior aircraft compared to the su27. (and it looks better too!) Copyright © The Global Aircraft OrganizationCopyright © The Global Aircraft Organization



TMT
Subject: F/A-22A vs Su-47
Post ID# 995
Message Number 13
Date Posted: 16 December 2005, 1:37:53 AM

Thank you Al...I keep listening to all of these dipsh*ts talk about the su-47's 'plasma stealth' and it's all bullsh*t. I even listened to some guy tell me how it's supposed to work. It's all fu*ken bullsh*t. Listen...the only thing that the Sukhoi's MIGHT have over the F-22 is IRST, (infa-red scanner/tracker) and that's literally it!



black_ace
Subject: F/A-22A vs Su-47
Post ID# 998
Message Number 14
Date Posted: 18 December 2005, 8:57:25 AM

It does have stealth,TMT, chill man



[ echo419 ]

Posts: 1
First post: 2007-11-15
Join date: 2007-11-15
Location: Georgia, USA
Group: Newcomer

GAViCs: 0.10
GAC Cards: 0 cards
Subject: F/A-22A vs Su-47
Post ID# 1418
Message Number 15
Date Posted: 15 November 2007, 9:17:50 PM

I just want to settle this thing here and now. Im going to give you three situations that the f-22 and su-47 could get in.

DOG FIGHT
In a dog fight a Su-47 would be dubbed the winner. Yes the F-22 has great manuverability but the forward swept wings of a Su-47 are designed to make it have tight turning and operations at sub sonic speeds, speeds in which dog fighting takes place. Yes, the F-22 is equiped with side winder missiles but the Su-47 has a new one the the Russians have designed. Once the pilot locks on to a target and fires a missle, that missile will go were ever the pilot looks. So even if the F-22 gets behind the Su-47, its new missile tech will trash the F-22. Not to mention that for the longest time Russia has been all about the dog fights. When American came with our F-4's(planes that only had missiles) and they came with Migs Fishbeds (planes with guns) the Mig would win most of the time.

BVRC(Beyond Visual Range Combat)
In this situation an F-22 would win. Everyone says that when an F-22 opens it's bomb bay doors it's stealth vanishes. True, but they only open for a fraction of a second and they dont plan to use only one F-22 durng combat. What im saying is they have 2 F-22's flying at once to shot down targets. What they have is a lead F-22 that is using passive radar systems to find targets. It will never shot a missile and will never be seen on radar. Now there is a trailing F-22 thats far away out of enemey radar. The lead F-22 transmits data to the trailing one and the trailing one fires a missile. The trailing one will never be seen because it is out of visual and radar range. Not to mention that the F-22 and Apache are the only aircraft that can engage multple enemeys at once. that means once one missile is fired they can move on to the next target. Fire and Forget....

GENERAL
If the F-22 and Su-47 were in battle F-22 wins. Its tactic is to shoot you down way before you even get close. They did a real test. 1 F-22 vs 4 F-16's. Before the F-16's finished getting to crusing altittude they had been shot down. American has always been about getting the technical advantage. The USAF wants its forces to have a 1-10 ratio. For ever 10 planes theres and F-22 waiting for them. The Su-47 is also way to expensive to put into production. The Russias only have it for export not import. No they wont let America have one so dont ask. Overall here are my findings:

F-22 is a better plane
Su-47 looks way cooler.



[ fightingfalcon ]

Posts: 54
First post: 2008-07-05
Join date: 2008-07-05
Location: Pennsylvania, USA
Group: Rookie

GAViCs: 20.10
GAC Cards: 0 cards
Subject: F/A-22A vs Su-47
Post ID# 1555
Message Number 16
Date Posted: 05 July 2008, 3:40:48 PM

well it depends on several things. The pilots awareness. the f/a-22s position the radar. the controllers alertness and the skill of the f/a 22 pilot. if all human error was eliminated and the f/a-22 wasn't stealth then I would say it is too close to call



harry [ v_bomber ]

Posts: 187
First post: 2008-08-01
Join date: 2008-08-01
Location: UK
Group: Volunteer

GAViCs: 0.60
GAC Cards: 2 cards
  Total Value: 26.00 GAViCs
  Max Value: 18.00 GAViCs
  Avg Value: 13.00 GAViCs
Subject: F/A-22A vs Su-47
Post ID# 1911
Message Number 17
Last Updated: 13 September 2008, 1:03:22 PM
Date Posted: 06 September 2008, 1:11:16 PM

Id say probably the su47 actually you yankees overestimate yourself its not complete stealth its low observable so if the radars right it will pick it up. If the russians sent the mig 31 foxhunter the f22 would be out of the sky pretty quick as of the foxhunters radar speed I say again and listen!!! Its LOW OBSERVABLE not STEALTH you idiots cant read properly
They've delivered it upside down!
- Anon RN Admiral.

F4 PhantomII



[ firstsgt_cap ]

Posts: 277
First post: 2007-05-21
Join date: 2007-05-21
Location: Illinois, USA
Group: Volunteer

GAViCs: 29.75
GAC Cards: 6 cards
  Total Value: 110.00 GAViCs
  Max Value: 20.00 GAViCs
  Avg Value: 18.33 GAViCs
Subject: F/A-22A vs Su-47
Post ID# 1940
Message Number 18
Last Updated: 13 September 2008, 11:34:31 AM
Date Posted: 13 September 2008, 11:28:18 AM

Actually, V, your wrong.........

For a few reasons, the Su-47 was never meant to be a production aircraft, and couldn't even shoot a 15 down.........31s are great and all, yeah they are big, fast and have a powerful radar. But if the E-3 Sentry, AWACS, cannot detect and F-22........then a Mig-31 sure as hell can't either.........

Along with that, the Mig-31 is NOT a maneuverable aircraft..........its big and cumbersome.........it was not meant to be be maneuverable either it is a long range, high speed interceptor to defend against the low altitude penetrates, cruise missiles, and to fill in the gaps in Russia's radar defense coverage. It was originally an upgrade to the Mig-25. And by the way, its not a Foxhunter, its a Foxhound.........

And Low Observability, means it looks like a bird, IF your radar is actually powerful enough to pick up a bird..............IT IS stealth.

Check your facts before you start ranting about people being idiots and not being able to read. It doesn't look very becoming.

Oh, and Echo up there, has a little too much confidence in an aircraft that is almost 40 years old, has never been combat tested, wasn't designed for combat, was a test aircraft, and will never be put into production. It was designed as a come back to our X-29, both the US and USSR figured out that forward swept wings don't work quite as well as we had hoped.



[ f22_raptor ]

f22_raptor

Posts: 4
First post: 2009-09-11
Join date: 2009-09-09
Location: Australia
Group: Newcomer

GAViCs: 1.35
GAC Cards: 0 cards
Subject: F/A-22A vs Su-47
Post ID# 2318
Message Number 19
Date Posted: 11 September 2009, 5:22:09 AM

Quote:
Heres something i have always wanted to know who would win the F/A-22 or the Su-47. Both are great aircraft but i don't know which one is better because they both have amazing specs tell me what you think.
Quote:
Heres something i have always wanted to know who would win the F/A-22 or the Su-47. Both are great aircraft but i don't know which one is better because they both have amazing specs tell me what you think.
hay im saying that they both are the same they both look good fly good and are the best so i dont think it is esey to say but i like the su47 is one of the best fighters but im going with my second fav aircraft the f22 yes my second my first is the airbus a380 i love it


<< First   [Prev]    of 2 pages )  


Search the forum:



You must be logged in to post on this forum! Please Log in now




Global Aircraft Forum and faces are
Copyright © 2025 The Global Aircraft Organization

GAC Forum v.1,7,2