[ oxusaf ]
Posts: 72
First post: 2007-02-17
Join date: 2007-02-16
Location: California, USA
Group: Rookie
GAViCs: 97.50
GAC Cards: 0 cards
Subject: F/A22 or X35? Which is better
Post ID# 1175
Message Number 11Date Posted: 21 March 2007, 7:27:46 AM The USAF did, in no way chose the F-22 over the F-35. They are both different planes and fill different roles. The F-22 is specifically an Air Superiority fighter, however since the budget numbers came out and they had to lower the original order numbers and then changed the F-22 to the F/A-22 to fill both the roles of Fighter and Attack. Since the F-35 is and was originally designed to be a multi role aircraft it was never in competition with the F/A-22.
Z_man [ z_man43 ]
Posts: 1
First post: 2007-05-14
Join date: 2007-04-23
Location: Texas, USA
Group: Newcomer
GAViCs: 0.10
GAC Cards: 0 cards
Subject: F/A22 or X35? Which is better
Post ID# 1213
Message Number 12Date Posted: 14 May 2007, 9:19:33 AM The x-35 is just an experimental fighter for the new upcoming joint-strike fighter, the f-35. The f-35 is designedto take off and land to cv using Vertical Short Take Off and Landing V/STOVL as well as land based landing sites. Although the f-35 is newer than the f-22, its no match for the f-22's air superiority. The f-35 is meant for all purposes such as aerial combat, bombing etc. (multi-role). Its a supersonic fighter, but overall, the f-22 beats the f-35 by a long shot by means of stealth, bombing, and aerial attack given that the f-22 has superb thrust vectoring abilities, not to mention that it is alot faster, with super cruise and top speeds in the upper mach 2 range.
[ oxusaf ]
Posts: 72
First post: 2007-02-17
Join date: 2007-02-16
Location: California, USA
Group: Rookie
GAViCs: 97.50
GAC Cards: 0 cards
Subject: F/A22 or X35? Which is better
Post ID# 1214
Message Number 13Date Posted: 16 May 2007, 8:23:32 AM My words exactly z_man, nice to see some one else with actual facts behind their statements and not patriotic bias.
[ firstsgt_cap ]
Posts: 277
First post: 2007-05-21
Join date: 2007-05-21
Location: Illinois, USA
Group: Volunteer
GAViCs: 29.75
GAC Cards: 6 cards Total Value: 110.00 GAViCs
Max Value: 20.00 GAViCs
Avg Value: 18.33 GAViCs
Subject: F/A22 or X35? Which is better
Post ID# 1217
Message Number 14Date Posted: 21 May 2007, 3:01:41 PM You can't really compare the Raptor and the JSF, they are meant to do different things and to replace different aircraft. The Raptor will replace the F-15 and the JSF will replace the F-16 and A-10. As for replacing the A-10 that is one of the dumbest things anyone has ever thought of considering you can't shoot it down, but it will take the air force a while to actually replace every thing.
Back on topic though, I think the 22 is better than the JSF because: #1The 22 actually has a cannon(only the Marine version of the JSF will have one) #2larger weapons capacity #3The JSF is downright ugly #4what do we need to spend more money on it for if it is just going to get replaced by the time they have actually fulfilled the whole order
[ firstsgt_cap ]
Posts: 277
First post: 2007-05-21
Join date: 2007-05-21
Location: Illinois, USA
Group: Volunteer
GAViCs: 29.75
GAC Cards: 6 cards Total Value: 110.00 GAViCs
Max Value: 20.00 GAViCs
Avg Value: 18.33 GAViCs
Subject: F/A22 or X35? Which is better
Post ID# 1218
Message Number 15Date Posted: 21 May 2007, 3:01:42 PM You can't really compare the Raptor and the JSF, they are meant to do different things and to replace different aircraft. The Raptor will replace the F-15 and the JSF will replace the F-16 and A-10. As for replacing the A-10 that is one of the dumbest things anyone has ever thought of considering you can't shoot it down, but it will take the air force a while to actually replace every thing.
Back on topic though, I think the 22 is better than the JSF because: #1The 22 actually has a cannon(only the Marine version of the JSF will have one) #2larger weapons capacity #3The JSF is downright ugly #4what do we need to spend more money on it for if it is just going to get replaced by the time they have actually fulfilled the whole order
[ oxusaf ]
Posts: 72
First post: 2007-02-17
Join date: 2007-02-16
Location: California, USA
Group: Rookie
GAViCs: 97.50
GAC Cards: 0 cards
Subject: F/A22 or X35? Which is better
Post ID# 1240
Message Number 16Date Posted: 25 May 2007, 10:30:40 PM Here is a little quiz for everyone. Can anyone tell me which aircraft the F/A-22 will be replacing?
[ firstsgt_cap ]
Posts: 277
First post: 2007-05-21
Join date: 2007-05-21
Location: Illinois, USA
Group: Volunteer
GAViCs: 29.75
GAC Cards: 6 cards Total Value: 110.00 GAViCs
Max Value: 20.00 GAViCs
Avg Value: 18.33 GAViCs
Subject: F/A22 or X35? Which is better
Post ID# 1243
Message Number 17Date Posted: 25 May 2007, 11:33:56 PM Are you serious? Its replacing the F-15C Eagle, at least its replacing all, but 178 Eagles for the time being.
Just so it is clear for everyone, the F-22, which is no longer the F/A-22 just the F-22, is replacing the F-15 and only the F-15. The JSF is repacling the F-16 and the A-10.
[ oxusaf ]
Posts: 72
First post: 2007-02-17
Join date: 2007-02-16
Location: California, USA
Group: Rookie
GAViCs: 97.50
GAC Cards: 0 cards
Subject: F/A22 or X35? Which is better
Post ID# 1244
Message Number 18Date Posted: 25 May 2007, 11:42:40 PM It is called called the F/A-22 because of the added capability to attack ground targets and air targets. Here I will spoil the quiz...it is going to replace the F-117 @ Holloman AFB in hence the A in F/A. It will be able to attack more targets with the same capability and defend itself if the need arrises.
[ firstsgt_cap ]
Posts: 277
First post: 2007-05-21
Join date: 2007-05-21
Location: Illinois, USA
Group: Volunteer
GAViCs: 29.75
GAC Cards: 6 cards Total Value: 110.00 GAViCs
Max Value: 20.00 GAViCs
Avg Value: 18.33 GAViCs
Subject: F/A22 or X35? Which is better
Post ID# 1245
Message Number 19Date Posted: 26 May 2007, 12:19:37 AM No, the air force changed it back, they had wanted to emphasize its ground attack capability. As for replacing the 117, as far as I know the JSF will cover that too. Not that it makes much of a difference the 117 is a waste of money.
Also currently the air force will not be receiving the amount of aircraft they require to be totally combat ready. So a much smaller force of F-22s and JSF's will actually be purchased.
[ oxusaf ]
Posts: 72
First post: 2007-02-17
Join date: 2007-02-16
Location: California, USA
Group: Rookie
GAViCs: 97.50
GAC Cards: 0 cards
Subject: F/A22 or X35? Which is better
Post ID# 1246
Message Number 20Date Posted: 26 May 2007, 1:37:49 PM I didn't want to pull this card but are you Active duty USAF, I am telling you as an active duty aircraft maintainer that it is the F/A-22 and it is replacing the F-117. If you are someone in the industry that knows more than I do about this then let me know but this is the latest and greatest news in the USAF.
|